Devlog · Impossible to Untie

How a bag of fishing lures became Impossible to Untie

A ball of four ropes, orange, yellow, blue and green, wound tightly through one another on a dark purple background
The four-rope ball, level 8. It's easier than the lure bag.

The bag

On a camping trip, one of our kids tied up a bag of fishing lures. He pulled every loop as tight as he could and told us it was impossible to untie.

We took that as a challenge and said we'd have it open in two minutes. We didn't. The bag sits at home today, still tied, with the lures inside.

A YouTube channel first

He had bigger plans for that knot. He wanted to start a YouTube channel where people try to untie things in tough spots, and whoever gets one open wins the prize.

He also loves puzzle games. Together we came up with a different version: an Android game. You still get the knot and the race to beat it, and you play on your phone.

What we built

In Impossible to Untie, a knot of rope floats on your screen. Drag a rope to pull it and drag empty space to turn the knot. With two fingers you can hold a loop open and feed an end through it.

We made the rope act like the rope on that bag. It can't pass through itself or another rope, so you get out of a knot by working slack through it. Yank an end and the knot cinches tighter. Rope squeezed inside a knot grips and keeps gripping after you let go, so you loosen the knot before you draw rope through.

A rope comes free when the game finds no knot left in it and no other rope hooked through it. Free every rope and you finish the level. The game has 24 levels so far:

What we gave up

We tried a mode with gravity on every level. An invisible hand held the middle of the knot, and the loose ends swung out and flopped back as you turned it. On a phone it was too much to follow, so we switched it off. You only meet gravity in the four hanging levels at the end, where something holds the rope up.

What's next

Impossible to Untie is in beta testing on Android. The lure bag is still tied.

Think you could open it in two minutes? Join the sign-up list on our homepage for playtest invites and release news.

Magic Man Labs is an indie studio in Minnesota.